The Last Airbender Movie Review
(This review was first written in 2018 and may not reflect my current standards of review. It's been posted here for archival sake with my other reviews)
…..*Sigh* What can really be said about this film that hasn’t been said already? It’s been almost a Decade and people are still talking about just how badly this film screwed up.
Now I know everyone and their mother has reviewed this film already..but I’m sorry..I want my slice of the movie bashing Pizza. Avatar holds a deep place in my heart. I was there the day it premiered in 2005 and I was there when it ended in 2008. From Boy in the Iceberg to Avatar Aang. I was there every step of the way and I grew up alongside Aang and his friends.
So naturally I got personal stake in this.
For the 10 of you who have no idea what I’m talking about The Last Airbender is a movie adaptation of the EXTREMELY popular and critically lauded series “Avatar the Last Airbender” The movie was Written and Directed by M Night Shyamalan. Well the cartoon has gone down as one of the best cartoons in the past 2 decades the movie has gone down as one of the the worst films in HISTORY and was a huge blow to M Nights already declining career until he was able to rebound with “the Visit” and “Split”.
And I’m gonna show you why it’s hated in just a few moments.
So let’s begin with a
Plot Summary.
So the movie opens up with the paramount and nickelodeon logos stylized with the paramount logo being water turning into ice and the Nickelodeon logo turning into fire(And trust me. Once this movie is done you’ll want to put paramount on ice and Nickelodeon on fire…)
Then we get...a sequence of the various bending elements being shown off with a red backdrop behind it. In other words the intro to the cartoon….in a movie….I don’t know why. Other than doing what the cartoon did what does this add? We don’t even get voiceover to this scene. Wouldn’t it be more appropriate to have Katara say the lines she said in the intro if you were gonna do this?
Next is a rip off of the opening to a star wars film. Seriously it’s a rolling wall of text describing the set up. Except it’s narrated by Katara. We can read Shamilyan! Also if you were gonna have Katara explain the premise wouldn’t it be better to show it off with..visuals? You know like the show did? It worked for Lord of the Rings in movie form!
And this opening wall of text isn’t even well done. For starters it doesn’t even mention the fact that the Fire Nation invaded despite being a part of the core premise of the show or the fact each nation has people who can control or “bend” it’s signature element. and when it describes the Four nations it lists them as “Water, Earth, Fire and Air Nomads” why would you give the designation of only one of the nations? Wouldn’t it be better to list it as “The Water Tribe, The Earth Kingdom, The Fire Nation and the Air Nomads” or just “Water, Earth, Fire and Air”?
But whatever the point is this is a world where four nations exist called the Water Tribe, The Earth Kingdom, The Fire Nation and Air Nomads. Each has special people known as “benders” who can control each of the 4 elements. For hundreds of years they lived in peace and prosperity until out of nowhere the Fire Nation declared war on the world. The only person who had the power to stop them was the Avatar the one person in the world who could bend all 4 elements at once. It was his duty to keep the peace between the 4 nations. But right around the time the war broke out he just...vanished.
See? THAT'S how you do a premise info dump!
Also right out of the gate the film lists itself as “book 1. Water”....Hah Hah….
We really open up with two of our main characters Katara and Sokka. Katara is bending some water into a ball and it lands on Sokka. Sokka gets mad and looks like he’s about to HIT Katara(!?) until Katara calms him down. Sokka mutters to not do that again. And man we’re off to a bad start. The show handled this so much better. The sequence of events in the show was a much better way of introducing these characters. The show had a comedic scene showing Sokka trying(and failing) to fish while Katara using her waterbending does it with ease but in the process getting Sokka wet annoying him. It shows these characters are funny and they have personality. But here all I know is it looks like a guy was about to HIT his younger sister for getting him wet.
We then get some more narration from Katara. Apparently their dad is off fighting in the war after their mom died. The two siblings are hunting for food because food is scarce during war time(Okay why the hell would food be scarce because of the war in the south pole? You know where the most recent raid was about 6 years ago? I know it’s a minor point but it just bugs me)
Sokka thinks he’s successfully tracked down some Tiger Seals only to find nothing. After an AWFUL bit of Dialogue where Sokka describes how he tracked them he sees something under the water. Sokka’s first reaction is to bash it with his boomerang...because that’s a smart move. Let’s crack the ice underneath us! It’s not like we won’t fall in!(By the way I should probably point out Katara and Sokka haven’t even been named yet. I’m just giving you their names for convenience sake)
A ball of ice emerges from the water and Sokka advises to...back away from it...what? BEcause it’s a fire nation trap? Double WHAT!? Then why did you bother to get it open in the first place? But Katara sees a person is in there and grabs Sokka’s boomerang and bursts the ball open releasing a beam of light that attracts the attention of...someone.
Katara and Sokka find out the person inside the ball is a boy along with a giant Bison. This is Aang our protagonist(Once again he’s not named as of yet but for convenience sake I’m giving it here) and his pet Sky Bison Appa. In the show even though he had just gotten out of being frozen he was still bubbly and upbeat. It showed that he was a lovable adventurous kid. In the movie...he just lays their weakly as Katara asks him questions...I think it’s probably worth pointing out the show made fun of this cliche…. Oh and we get a failed bit of comedy when Appa’s tail falls on Sokka and he thinks it’s trying to eat him. It’s a gag that probably would have worked better if it was in animation with exaggeration.
Then we get a bit of awkward editing. We see an establishing shot of the South Pole and we see some villagers looking at something in the distance...but then it cuts to Aang inside a hut getting dressed as we see get a look at his tattoos. Was there supposed to be a scene of Katara, Sokka, Aang and Appa arriving in the village that got cut or something? Considering that at least 30 minutes of footage was cut from the film it’s a definite possibility
And Aang starts talking to Katara explaining why he was in a ball of ice in another scene with AWFUL dialogue. And I might as well just bring it up now. Most of the acting in this movie is ATROCIOUS. None of these actors have any of the energy and life needed to portray these characters. All the performances are either stitled or disinterested. I’ll get more into the specific examples in the analysis section but needless to say it just makes the already bad dialogue even more bad.
Then we see a Fire Nation ship arrive. Sokka warns Katara and Aang and Katara advises Aang to stay hidden. Sokka wants to attack but Katara advises him not to(because why would we want an action scene in our action film? -_- )The fire nation invade the village and we’re introduced to Prince Zuko...who looks nothing like he did in the show. At least with Sokka, Katara and Aang they bothered to make them look like their characters(Sorta) but Zuko doesn’t even REMOTELY resemble his cartoon counterpart. He demands all the elderly be given to him.(Of course the reason why is because he expects the Avatar to be an old guy but we never hear the explanation for this making it look like...well honestly it makes him look like he’s got a fetish) When Katara and Sokka’s grandmother Kanna is brought up Katara starts to waterbend to save her but Sokka tells her not to. Um. Weren’t YOU the one who was itching to take them down?
Also this scene also highlights a glaring issue. Katara, Sokka and their grandma are the only white people in an inuit tribe. I’ll get more into this after the plot summary but needless to say this is a part of the “Racebending” criticism the film has gotten.
One of the men finds Aang and brings him to Zuko, Zuko demands Aang come with him or he’ll burn down the village. Aang agrees and is taken away. Okay I need to bring this up. This is supposed to be an action film right? So wouldn’t this be a good place for an action scene? Like Sokka seeing his grandmother taken away engages in battle with the fire nation and Katara and Aang step in to help. Aang reveals he’s an airbender during this making Zuko realize he’s the Avatar. He threatens to burn the village down if Aang doesn’t surrender and come with him and Aang agrees.
Wouldn’t that be a much BETTER scene than what we got?
In the next scene Katara and Sokka are moping about Aang being taken away with Katara saying it’s all their fault for not fighting(See even the characters think there should have been an action scene!) and also says the boy is their responsibility even comparing it to how Sokka protects her….you JUST MET AANG 2 HOURS AGO AND YOU DON’T EVEN KNOW HIS NAME. This made more sense in the show where Katara and Sokka had over a day and a half to bond with Aang and we were shown scenes of Aang becoming friends with them. But here...nothing!
Oh and this scene also has this exchange between the two.
Katara“What would you do if they took me away?”
Sokka“I’d kill them all.”
Our goofy but useful comic relief ladies and gentlemen….seriously Jackson Rathbone’s portrayal of Sokka in this film is just like Anakin in the Star Wars prequels…except arguably worse
Then they see some kids playing with Appa and the two gaze in amazement at Appa flying...by the way this is one of only about 4 scenes where we see Appa clearly. Enjoy it.
Then after a really abrupt cut we see Aang in Zuko’s ship talking to him and Iroh. And like Zuko Iroh doesn’t look anything like his cartoon counterpart. He says he just wants to perform tests on Aang and Aang agrees. And it’s at this point Aang's actor Noah Ringer is REALLY starting to bug me. He sounds so bored. And that’s not Aang! He should be filled with life even in a dire situation like this!
Another abrupt cut and we’re with Sokka and Katara talking to their grandmother...in one of the worst info dumps I’ve ever seen. Kanna starts expositing about that boy Aang has to be the Avatar because he’s an Airbender. Of course she doesn’t explain WHY she knows he’s the Avatar because he’s Airbender because the movie is trying to make the genocide of the Air Nomads a big reveal...even though it’s in THE TITLE OF THE FILM. She also starts explaining about the spirits in the spirit world and how they work. You know information that was imparted through scattered knowledge to allow the viewer to piece it together by themselves in the show. Because it understood it’s audience WEREN’T IDIOTS.
But then we get a weird change. Apparently the fire nation declared war on the world because...they didn’t wanna live by the spirits rules and they fear the Avatar because he’s the bridge between the Spirit and physical world. Okay what the hell is this? In the show the Fire nation invaded because they wanted to take over the world! Plain and simple! The reason they wanted the Avatar out of the picture was because he was the only one with the power to stop them! Why would you change something like that? Also she mentions something about the Avatar having the power to change hearts and it's through that they can stop all wars...what does that even mean? Anyway she tells Katara and Sokka it’s their destiny to help Aang.
Back to Aang he’s getting tested by Zuko and Iroh and the test involves….put a stone, a fire and water in front of Aang...and they react to his presence….is...is this implying that all benders or at least the Avatar are subconsciously bending their element whenever they are near it? Because that’s really stupid(And I shouldn’t have to tell you this wasn’t in the show) Anyway this shows them that Aang is the Avatar. Zuko orders him locked up but Aang somersaults over him with Airbending and Zuko just...stands there...yeah he screams “Stop” but he doesn’t even attempt to stop him. In the show Aang could have made that movement so fast Zuko and Iroh couldn’t react but in the movie it’s so slow it looks awkward.
Aang runs on deck with his staff(Even though he wasn’t seen with it in the last scene) and deploys his glider. Zuko orders him to stop and says “you’ve got nowhere to run”...He’s got a Glider and he’s an Airbender. WHAT DID YOU THINK HE WAS GONNA DO!? Also another perfect opportunity for an action scene and they don’t take it.
Aang glides away and meets up with Katara and Sokka. He says he’s going back to his home and Katara and Sokka offer to come along because…..they have nothing better to do? Yeah like I said earlier this made more sense in the show because Katara and Sokka had 2 episodes to get attached to Aang. But here they barely know Aang so them coming along looks like they’re just doing it because they’ve got nothing better to do with their time.
Oh and I hope you enjoyed the South Pole scenes because filming them on location in Greenland ate up most of the budget. The horrible effects? The cheap sets? We have these scenes to blame for them.
We see the newly formed Team Avatar live action edition flying to the Southern Air Temple as Katara explains through voice over how Aang flew away and got forced into a storm by Appa- HEY WAIT A MINUTE! We KNOW This already! Aang told them this in an earlier scene! Did no one proof read this!?
Aang starts exploring the Southern Air Temple asking where everyone is but no one responds to him. Aang is sure his guardian and father figure Monk Gyatso will jump out and surprise him. Katara asks for Aang's name….even though she MENTIONED IT IN THE LAST SCENE also why didn’t you ask on the way here? You can have stuff like that happen offscreen!
They come across a flying lemur that begins crawling around on Aang. and it’s clear Noah Ringer has NO IDEA what’s supposed to be on his shoulders. Katara is confused because she thought Flying Lemurs were extinct but Aang says there are millions...and Katara suddenly realizes Aang's friends are Air Nomad monks….he’s an airbender….he lived at the southern air temple...you just NOW realized this!? He even mentioned a MONK Gyatso! What? did you think that Monk was his first name?!
Aang runs off before Katara can tell him what happened and Aang finds a field of bones. Katara reveals to Aang that the Fire Nation killed all the Air Nomads and that he must have been in the ice for over 100 years. Katara the Avatar disappeared a 100 years ago….OF COURSE HE WAS FROZEN FOR 100 YEARS!. Also this scene is played out like a big reveal even though as I mentioned earlier Aang being the last airbender is IN THE TITLE.And this was a problem the show didn’t have! The show was smart enough to make it clear that Aang was the last airbender from the get go. The tension comes from the fact we’re wondering how Aang is gonna react when he learns he’s the last of his kind.
Aang goes into the denial stage of grief insisting Katara is lying(Why would she lie?) and then he sees a necklace he made for Monk Gyatso. He says he made it for him...and then we see a flashback where we see him give it to him(One or the other M Night…). Aang screams “NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!” and his eyes start glowing. He starts whipping up a storm as Sokka and Katara are pelted by bad CGI wind. It’s Laughably bad. Aang enters...the spirit world I guess and he sees a dragon...okay what the hell is this!? Is this supposed to be Roku the previous Avatar and Aang's mentor in the show? I have no idea because they don’t say if it is or not they just call him “The Dragon Spirit”. This is probably my least favorite part of the entire film because it’s probably an encapsulation of all the issues with it. What’s the point of changing Aang’s mentor into a random Dragon rather than Roku? Why did they feel the need to do this? Nothing! The only thing it accomplishes is WASTING MONEY ON THE EFFECTS. Wouldn’t it be easier to show a guy in a costume? LIKE ROKU!?! The Dragon asks Aang where he’s been and Katara and Sokka snap Aang back to reality.
Then we see our main villain Admiral Zhao spying on Zuko’s ship through a spyglass. He says to offer him lunch and then we cut to...Zuko and Iroh having lunch with Zhao Okay what? That was another really abrupt cut. Shouldn’t we have a scene of Zuko and Iroh meeting with Zhao and THEN eating lunch with him!? Oh and then we get another info dump as Zhao expositis Zuko’s backstory to people who should ALREADY KNOW IT. He even opens up with “As you know”. Although to be fair the way he’s wording it makes it clear he’s doing it to mock Zuko. Anyway we learn that Zuko was banished from his home by his father and the only way he can return home is if he captures the Avatar. Zuko is enraged by Zhao’s speech but is calmed down by Iroh and Zuko tells Zhao when he’s king he’ll bow before him. Then Zuko and Iroh leave...in a shot that lingers on for WAY too long.
We then get a brief scene of Zuko blowing off steam by training with his troops. By the way I should point out this is the first real action scene of the movie and not only is it really short it comes in at the 25 minute mark.
Cut back to Team Avatar where they are making camp. Appa just...randomly flies away….huh? Oh right can’t have him eating up the effects. Katara asks Aang if he’s okay and if he’s the Avatar. Aang dodges the question and asks how much does the fire nation control. We then get MORE exposition as Katara explains about how the Fire Nation establishes colonies and how they’re looking to take over Omashu and Ba Sing Se. Except SHE SHOULDN’T KNOW MOST OF THIS STUFF. She was raised in the South Pole away from most of the earth kingdom!
Also you guys have been traveling together for at least 3 days. ONE where are you going? And TWO you didn’t ask if he was the Avatar at all during those 3 days?
Then a boy runs up to him followed by some fire nation troops. Katara asks why they want him and the soldier says it’s because he was throwing rocks from them behind a tree and it hurt….Ladies and gentlemen our villains Wimps who can’t handle kids throwing rocks at them. Katara expresses surprise the boy is an earth bender….um..Katara you don’t need earthbending to throw rocks. She says that no one is taking the boy anywhere and Sokka agrees...Okay are these two just REALLY clingy to people or something? I can buy they wouldn’t let the kid get taken away but the way it’s worded suggests the boy they just met 2 seconds ago is their responsibility too.
Then Katara tries to waterbend but accidently freezes Sokka in a HORRIBLE looking effect. Could that ice on him look any more fake? and is this really the time for comedy? Also Katara in the show had a blunder like this but IN the show she responded back with quick thinking by bending backwards. But in the movie it just cuts to them getting caught implying they just gave up? What she didn’t try again? Aang didn’t try to step in?
After getting caught they’re thrown into a prison with other Earthbenders….in a ROCK QUARRY...HOW STUPID IS THE FIRE NATION!? That’s like locking Aquaman in a room filled with rising water!
We get some exposition from the earthbending boys father on how the Fire Nation came in with their “machines” and Sokka mentions how the Fire nations goal is to suppress other bending...then why not just KILL the Earthbenders? It’s not like they’re the good guys! And if you’re trying to suppress bending DON’T PUT THEM IN A ROCK QUARRY! Aang even points this out when he gives his pep talk to them. Saying he’s the Avatar and he’s here to save them.
A fire nation soldier questions this pointing out the Avatar would have to be an airbender….He’s got the tattoos you idiot!
Also this is supposed to be a big moment. Aang has(seemingly) accepted his role as the Avatar and is ready to save some people who have needed him for so long. But nothing in this scene supports this. There’s no music, the acting is bad and the cinematography is bland. It feels so dull.
Katara, Aang and Sokka gear up to fight
“Okay...everyone can help us now!”
Hey look an actual line that sounds like Sokka would say. That’s a rarity.
Then we get...probably the worst scene in the entire film….
The Earthbenders finally decide to fight and we get the first actual full on good guy vs bad guy action scene in the film. It’s laughably stupid.
For starters the bending. In the show the bending movements were based on actual martial art skills in order to symbolize the flow of combat. But in here whenever ever a character bends they just do some sort of little dance and then the element action appears. Just as an example we see 6 earthbenders doing exaggerated movements...just to move a tiny rock for another Earthbender to smash into one fire nation soldier. That’s a NOVICE MOVE for ONE BENDER in the show. The movement the actors do has nothing to do with what the element does and it just makes the bending look comical.
Second. This entire scene just shows that M Night has no clue how to shoot an action scene. The whole thing is done in ONE TAKE. You NEVER do something like this. If you’re gonna do an action scene in one take it not only slows the action down but it shows all the holes in the choreography and shows all the people waiting for their turn to do something just awkwardly standing around. This movie makes me miss Michael Bay’s fast paced cut action scenes!
Third this entire scene just shows how much this work FAILS as an Adaptation. This whole sequence is essentially an adaption of the episode “Imprisoned” except there the prison was on a metal island so the reason the earthbenders couldn’t fight back MADE SENSE. And even when Team Avatar got them coal so they could fight back they were still reluctant to do so because of how broken they were by this point. In the film I’m not sure who the bigger idiot is. The Earthbenders for not fighting back sooner or the Fire Nation for putting them in a quarry in the first place.I understand not being able to do the prison on the water for budget reasons but why not just have a regular metal prison or even a wooden one? Are you seriously telling me you couldn’t afford a simple PRISON SET!? And in the show it’s KATARA who gives the speech to motivate the Earthbenders showing she’s a strong character but in the movie it’s Aang. I get WHY they did it. The film needed a moment showing Aang accepting his role as the Avatar but it just stands out given Katara barely does ANYTHING in this film.
Finally. This is the first actual action scene in the film...20 minutes in! And what did it accomplish? Aside from making both the fire nation and earthbenders look like morons? The only purpose this scene serves in the narrative is to have Aang accept his destiny(Which could have been done differently and isn’t well done anyway) and to show off how Earthbending looks because after this we never see Earthbending again.
Then we get a scene of the grateful villagers giving them some bending scrolls that the Fire Nation troops locked up(Why didn’t the Fire Nation just burn them) among the scrolls is a waterbending scroll that Katara is interested in. Then we see Aang looking at a statue of Avatar Kyoshi the last Earthbender Avatar. The village elder mentions that Kyoshie “Loved Games” which is a Sentiment Aang can stand behind. Really? Because Kyoshi never struck me as the gaming type in the show in the brief glimpses we got of her. I’m guessing this is a misinterpretation of the Avatar cycle. That every Avatar has the same personality because they are the same person reincarnated. Also if their in a village that honor’s Kyoshi where are the Kyoshi warriors? Oh right that scene was cut never mind.
Well after that waste of screen time Sokka proposes going around freeing other villages when Aang mentions he ran away from home before he could learn the other forms of bending. Katara asks why and Aang says it’s because the monks told him the Avatar couldn’t have a family and it’s a sacrifice every Avatar must make to keep peace in the world. Well what do you know another stupid change. In the show there was no rule against the Avatar never having a family! They aren’t freaking prequel Jedi! Roku was married and had kids, the aforementioned Kyoshi had a daughter and in Legend of Korra it’s revealed Aang had his own family. Aang had run away from home because they were gonna take him away from his guardian/father figure Gyatso and everything and everyone he loved because the monks felt it was distracting him from his training.
But whatever the point is Aang hasn’t learned all the forms of bending yet so Sokka proposes they head to the northern water tribe to learn Waterbending(You know something they came to the conclusion much faster in the show because they had more time to flesh out everything). And apparently it’s run by a princess since her father died(Sure why not?) and Aang agrees(Wait where were they going before deciding to go to the NWT?). You know this scene is REALLY awkwardly shot. It’s really close up and the cutting is rapid..it’s so..distracting. Did they originally plan for the adventure with the Kyoshi warriors to impart this information but when those scenes got cut they had to film this scene in reshoots in order to make the plot work? Probably would explain why everyone is so close up and why the background looks green screened.
And then we get a brief montage of Aang and co freeing other villages in the Earth Kingdom and Zuko stalking them. Then we get to some narration from Katara saying Aang is having trouble with waterbending as we see her and Aang practice...with NO EFFECTS. They REALLY must have stretched that budget thin….
Cut to the Fire Nation where Zhao is talking with...oh what the hell is this...Zhao is talking with Fire Lord Ozai...whose face we can clearly see. Oh my gosh you did it movie. You ruined one of the best villains in the show! In the show Ozai’s face was always concealed in shadow until the third season and every single time we saw him the crew made sure to make sure he was intimidating as possible shadowed face or not. But here...he’s just..there. There’s no mood, no interesting lighting no intimidating soundtrack. Zhao doesn’t bow before the might of the firelord. He just talks to him like an average joe. The problem isn’t that they show his face the problem is that they don't bother to make him look menacing. It certainly doesn’t help that Ozai’s actor Cliff Curtis is not naturally intimidating.
But whatever Zhao mentions he found something in a hidden library about the moon and ocean spirit being in physical form in the northern water tribe and how they could destroy them to prove the fire nation is no match for the spirits...or something. Ozai asks about the Avatar and Zhao says it’s under control and then….Oazi tells Zhao he better hope for his sake that his son doesn’t find him first because if he does he would be welcomed home as a hero and be Zhao’s superior. And that one line is probably one of the biggest misinterpretations of the entire film. M Night seems to have taken the deal Ozai gave Zuko at face value. That he would welcome him back with open arms once he found the Avatar. Except in the show Oazi never had any intention of welcoming Zuko back. By the time Zuko was banished the Avatar had been missing for 97 years so Ozai was essentially sending Zuko on a massive goose chase because his plan was to punish him through cruelty and neglect. It was just plain dumb luck that Zuko happened to come across the Avatar one day! Maybe the idea is that Ozai is trying to manipulate Zhao to work harder but the line is read with such sincerity it doesn’t come across that way.
Cut to a Fire Nation colony where Zuko and Iroh are having dinner. Iroh tells Zuko he should just let go of his quest to find the Avatar and settle down. Zuko says no and has a boy come up to explain why. He asks the Boy(Who according to the credits it’s Jet{?!}) to tell him the “story of the banished prince” and the boy and Zuko take turns explaining Zuko’s backstory. Apparently Zuko spoke out against a general who was gonna sacrifice some of his friends in a battle- OKAY STOP!! Why did the people the general was gonna sacrifice have to be some of Zuko’s friends? In the show they were just some new recruits. The point of that scene was to show that Zuko cared about his PEOPLE whether he knew them or not! He cared about the soldiers fighting in the war. Changing them to his friends dilutes the entire point of that moment!
Then the boy says Zuko was forced into an Agni Kai duel. Zuko thought it was gonna be the general but instead it was his own father(It was because he had spoke out in his father Ozai’s throne room but the movie doesn’t bother to explain this). We see a Flashback of the fight and Zuko begs for mercy and apparently Ozai says that if he didn’t wanna fight he should have sent his sister out to beat him and Zuko’s sister steps forward...is that supposed to be an insult? Zuko is supposed to beat his sister because she’s a little girl? IT’S AZULA! One of the most dangerous benders in the show! And why would Oazai use an emasculating comment towards his favorite child? Anyway those who have seen the show knows how this goes. Zuko refuses to fight and gets burned and because he refused to fight he was banished with his only hope of returning being to capture the Avatar.
Also that was an exposition scene where EVERYONE PRESENT KNEW THIS. For Pete’s sake Iroh was there! He should know this! And this is the second time this has happened for Zuko! Wouldn’t a better way to do this be to have a flashback that Zuko dwells on? Or did you HAVE to have narration over said flashback?
Then we get Katara and Aang practicing Waterbending(Again no actual waterbending is taking place) and katara notices Aang seems distracted. Aang says they’re close to the northern air temple and asks if he can go there saying he’ll only be gone for a day...then we just cut right to Katara talking with Sokka about it. No transition, no lead in it just cuts right to them talking...it’s so abrupt it nearly gave me whiplash!. Sokka says no because...the script says so? He says “They Started a Rebellion” but that has nothing to do with what’s going on. He tells Katara to talk Aang out of it. And of course Katara who was on Aang’s side before just relents because Sokka said so...character assassination at it’s finest folks. Show Katara NEVER would have given into Sokka’s bullcrap and it took a whole season for her to start deferring to him.
That night Aang is practicing waterbending(And this time there ARE effects but the movement of the water has nothing to do with what his hands are doing…) and he gets a vision of Monk Gyatso and his friends followed by a bunch of skulls and bones. This causes his waterbending to stop and Aang runs off to the Air Temple. Sokka and Katara notice this and Sokka says “Guess your talk didn’t work”
TALK!? What talk!? There was no scene of Katara trying to talk Aang out of it! What did it end up on the cutting room floor or something!? Also it’s HERE that Sokka brings up a valid point on why Aang shouldn’t go to the northern Air Temple. The Fire Nation is following them. Would have been nice to bring that up earlier Sokka…
Aang arrives at the Northern Air Temple(By the way if you’re hoping to see the mechanist prepare to be disappointed) and he runs into a random old guy. The old guy seems pleased to see Aang. Aang says something about the Fire Nation “Destroyed this place” Really? It looks pretty intact to me. Devoid of most life but intact. The old man tells Aang there is one place left untouched. The room of statues of previous Avatars.
When they get inside said room(By the way this is the ONLY part of the film where they mention Roku) he asks how the monks new Aang was the Avatar and Aang says he was given a test. What’s the point of bringing this up? It’s not relevant to anything it’s just pointless exposition. Aang mentions that he was supposed to be part of a ceremony where he accepts his role as the Avatar. All the monks bow to him and Aang bows back symbolizing him taking on the role. But according to Aang “I didn’t bow back”. Okay I’ll be honest that’s not a bad change and I could certainly see something like that being in the show. The problem of course is Noah Ringers acting. It REALLY hurts this scene. He’s giving it his all I can tell but it’s just not happening.
The old man asks for forgiveness...and a bunch of archers come from behind the statues(What were they just waiting there for days?). Turns out the old man betrayed Aang because “Your absence caused me to live in poverty”....What? How does that even make sense? The Old Man is given a bag of silver and we never see him again.
Cut to Aang in chains. He starts to have a vision in the spirit world where the Dragon Spirit tells Aang he’s seen a vision of the moons destruction and Aang must stop it by going to the Northern Water Tribe. THE PLACE HE WAS ALREADY GOING TO. Then Zhao enters the scene and just casually talks with Aang asking him how he could be the Avatar and just a boy. If this is supposed to be intimidating it’s not done well at all. There’s no imposing music and Asaif Mambi’s performance as Zhao doesn’t really sell it. He says he won’t kill Aang because he’ll just be reborn again if it happens
Then we see a guy in a blue mask infiltrate the temple as Zhao gives a speech to his soldiers. Blue Mask guy breaks Aang out and we get...one of the worst fight scenes I’ve ever seen. Like with the earlier Earthbending scene the entire thing is done in one take and all the same problems are there. The action is slowed down and you see all the holes in the choreography. The thing that makes it worse is that you can see that Aang and Blue Mask guy are SURROUNDED but apparently the bad guys have the courtesy to not rush them and attack 2 or 3 at a time. It’s so stupid. There’s even a scene where Blue Mask Guy shoves his sword AT NOTHING.
The fight ends with Zhao ordering them not to kill the Avatar….okay….just because they were fighting doesn’t mean they’d kill him. Blue Mask guy puts his sword on Aang threatening to kill him and Zhao reluctantly allows them to leave...even though they were some guys behind them that could have snuck up behind Blue Mask guy and stopped him! This made more sense in the show where Blue Mask guy and Aang were right up against the gate.
Blue Mask guy still holding Aang hostage takes Aang outside and over the bridge and Zhao orders his archers to fire. Blue Mask guy gets hit with an arrow and is knocked unconscious. Okay. In the show they had archers who could pin a fly to a tree without killing it but it’s clear from the way the scene is shot that THEY COULDN’T SEE BLUE MASK GUY AND HE WAS BLOCKED OFF BY THE BRIDGE.
Aang takes off Blue guys mask revealing to absolutely no one's surprise Zuko. This scene is played up as a BIG DEAL and Aang being surprised Zuko saved him except Aang and Zuko have only met each other ONCE in the film up to this point and Zuko didn’t really give much of a negative impression aside from wanting to capture him. So Aang really doesn’t have that much to go on when judging Zuko whereas he did in the TV show where Aang and Zuko ran into multiple times and it always ended with the two coming to blows and in one case a village nearly burning down.
Aang creates a fog cover to help them escape and Zhao says
“What is this?”
IT'S FOG YOU IDIOT!
Cut to Aang looking over an injured Zuko. He stares intensely at Zuko and...leaves...what was the point of that? In the show as Zuko woke up Aang talked to Zuko about how if things were different they could have been friends as it was shown if they made a good team but Zuko just firebended at him causing Aang to flee. It was supposed to be foreshadowing to Zuko’s eventually turn to good in the final season. They even had the set up for the scene because Aang felt the need to start a fire(Oh yeah in the movie firebenders need existing fire to bend...i’ll get to this later). But here Aang just...leaves...what did they forget to film the scene or something?
Cut to the firelord's chamber where Zhao gives the news to Ozai that he thinks the Blue Spirit who took the Avatar was Zuko….um..how did you come to this conclusion? In the show Zhao found out because while he was “acquiring” Zuko’s crew for his Siege of the Northern Water Tribe he saw the duel swords in Zuko’s chamber and put two and two together. But here there’s no given reason why he thought that. And why is this scene shot so we can’t see Ozai’s face? We’ve seen it already! You aren’t turning that around! Did they plan not to show his face originally but changed their minds later but forgot to reshoot this scene?
Zuko goes back to his ship and Iroh asks where he’s been but Zuko refuses to answer. We get voiceover as Ozai tells Zhao to leave his son to isolation and Zhao agrees….so naturally Zhao blows up Zuko’s ship. Of course in the show that’s EXACTLY the thing Ozai would have ordered but I already covered how the movie completely misinterpreted the relationship between Zuko and Ozai so I shouldn’t have to go over it again.
Next it’s Team Avatar arriving at the Northern Water Tribe...an hour into this film….and they’ve skipped over a LOT of important details that were missed in season 1. But whatever they are at the Northern Water Tribe. They go to the leaders of the tribe where we get...more voice over from Katara instead of an actual scene….oh and she just casually says “My brother and princess Yue became friends right away” because why bother showing a romance bloom when instead you can just sum it all up! I understand they didn’t have time to do a fully fleshed out romance but that’s what a montage is for. Aang shows he’s the Avatar and the northern Water Tribe knowing a siege will be imminent starts preparing.
We get another abrupt cut to Aang and Katara’s waterbending teacher Master Pakku making war plans I should probably point out they haven’t properly introduced Master Pakku when the scene cuts to him. I only gave his name for convenience sake but the movie expects you to know who he is right away! He says Princess Yue must be guarded and Sokka volunteers. Much like with the scene with Aang after Zuko is revealed as the Blue Spirit this is played up as big moment but because we haven’t seen Yue and Sokka’s relationship grow it falls flat!
Cut to Zhao and the Firelord talking. This scene is completely pointless aside from telling us stuff we already know moving on.
Katara and Aang are practicing Waterbending with Pakku. He says something about water being the element of change and that in order to master it you have to let your emotions flow through you and it teaches acceptance….um..that’s not how waterbending worked in the show…. Anyway Aang and Pakku spar for a bit but when it’s Aangs turn to go on the offensive he gets another flash of his Airbender friends and he hesitates and his waterbending fails….believe it or not this is going somewhere...not anywhere GOOD but it’s going somewhere.
Next we get Zhao talking on his ship with Iroh where Zhao thanks Iroh for joining his invasion...then proceeds to mock him for not only losing the siege of Ba Sing Sae but also for the loss of his son and Zuko….okay aside from giving exposition to the audience what was the point of that? Zhao in the show was an ass but he respected Iroh enough to not rub his failures in his face.
Then we get a scene of Yue and Sokka allegedly bonding. I say allegedly because Sokka and Yue’s actors have NO chemistry. Apparently it’s been weeks since Team Avatar got here….WEEKS!?! IT’S BEEN WEEKS!? The editing on this film has been so fast paced it feels like days! Also we get some REALLY awkward dialogue between Sokka and Yue when Sokka asks Yue about her white hair. Yue says it’s because she was stillborn but her father prayed to the moon spirit granting her life. This is the one character scene for Sokka in the entire film and even IT is plagued with the exposition curse. Though in fairness this is actually a rare improvement on the show because in the show Yue didn’t reveal her history with the moon spirit until it became important.
Iroh goes into the belly of the ship where he meets with Zuko. He warns Zuko about going ahead with the plan but Zuko insists he has to go through with it.
Then we get too..another scene of Aang and Katara waterbending WITH NO EFFECTS. It’s LAUGHABLE how obvious there was supposed to be an effect there. Then we get black snow. The sign of a fire nation invasion. I’d say pants to be darkened but the movie doesn’t make me care enough.
We get a scene of Zuko getting into a small boat preparing to sneak his way into the city. Iroh tells him to be careful and to use his “chi” to keep him warm. This is probably the only scene that actually manages to properly capture something that was in the show. Iroh and Zuko’s actors are probably the only two who are at least trying to properly adapt their counterparts. Sadly it’s too late to save this film. Zuko insists he’ll be fine and rows off.
He comes to a random location and dives in the water and dies instantly from hypothermic shock….okay he doesn’t die but without the shows ability to generate his own fire there’s no way Zuko could survive. I mean it’s not like he’s gonna burn through the ice like he did in the show….so then Zuko burns through the ice to get into the city like he did in the show...WHAT THE HELL!? The movie had established that Firebenders can’t create their own fire! How can Zuko suddenly generate his own heat now!? Oh right because we have to follow what the show did….
Aang goes to Yue and tells her he needs a place to meditate in order to get the Dragon Spirits advice on how to fight the fire nation. Yue knows a place and she Aang, Sokka and Katara begin to go there. On the way we see Zuko stalking them. Hey you know what this movie lacks? ZUKO HUNTING AANG. I brought this up earlier but Zuko and Aang have barley crossed paths in the film. Sure we’ve seen scenes of Zuko stalking him but nothing really intimidating. It makes this brief scene of him stalking them now hard to take seriously.
Team Avatar arrives at the sacred place a spring in the middle of a glacier. By the way this is the ONLY moment where Momo’s name is mentioned in the entire film when Momo tries to catch a fish. Then Aang randomly says
“To get your airbending tattoos you have to meditate for long periods of time. Some of the great monks can meditate for four days.”
Why did you say that? What was the point of saying that? How is that RELEVANT to what is going on in this scene? How is this information useful!? And to add insult to injury that’s not how Air Nomads get their tattoos!
So after saying that completely pointless line Aang starts to meditate. Yue says she needs to get back and Sokka goes with her. WHY!? Why do you need to leave? Oh that’s right it’s a contrivance so Katara can be left alone with Aang! In the show Yue only left because Zuko arrived and she’s not a fighter so she ran away.
Left alone with Aang Katara starts saying “I always knew you were real...I always knew you’d return”...Why did you say that? Like with the earlier “meditate” line what is the point of saying that right now? Isn’t this something you should have told him earlier? Oh and then Zuko shows up with a torch to capture Aang. Katara recognizes him from WAY BACK in the beginning of the film. Zuko uses his torch to set the grass on fire and the two square off.
Are we really supposed to take this scene seriously.Because up until this point Katara has been utterly useless in a fight! More than that she’s been shown as a danger to her ALLIES. By all rights Zuko should be able to wreck her shit. By this point in the show Katara had become an experience waterbending who could go toe to toe with Zuko...but in the movie….she pushed a guy?
Also the fight is just BORING it’s just Zuko throwing fireballs and Katara blocking them.
Zuko “Who are you?”
Katara “My name is Katara...and I’m the only waterbender left in the southern water tribe”
I’m absolutely certain that line was supposed to be spoken in a badass way. But Nicola Peltz’s acting ruins it...she sounds so nervous and confused and it just kills the tension. I’ll get more into this in the character section but she’s probably the worst character in the entire movie.
Zuko eventually manages to to beat her(compare that to the show where Katara would have won if it weren’t for the sun rising giving Zuko a power boost) and steals the Avatar but not before apologizing to Katara.
Cut to scenes of the fire nation invading. Including Master Pakku...howling a battle cry? Trust me it sounds goofier. During the fight Iroh warns Zhao the waterbenders have the advantage at night but Zhao assures Iroh it’s okay thanks to the scroll he got from the great library. Also despite the fact Pakku brought up they should put out all the torches during the battle NO ONE SEEMS TO HAVE GONE THROUGH WITH THIS.
Sokka and Yue find Katara unconcious(gee maybe you shouldn’t have left him) and Katara tells them Zuko took Aang. From there we see Zuko with Aang still unconscious and tied up hiding out in a random house till the battle stop. And he doesn’t just slip out in the confusion because?....The script said so?
Then we get Aang in the spirit world. He goes to the dragon for advice on the fire nation. The Dragon tells him 3 things. One that he isn’t dealing with the loss of his people and it's affecting his waterbending. 2 That the Avatar isn’t meant to hurt others(Wrong Avatars are allowed to keep peace however they want. And why learn bending if not to hurt people? What is Aang supposed to TALK the firelord into giving up?) and 3 he should use the power of water to stop the fire nation….USE WATER...that’s his big piece of advice to Aang? USE WATER!?! Is...is this real? Is this some kind of joke!? Because Water beats fire is KINDA OBVIOUS! This made FAR more sense in the show where Aang’s journey to the spirit world was to find out where the Ocean and Moon spirits were to get their help in defeating the fire nation. Not generic advice!
Aang wakes up and Zuko apparently decided to vent mentioning his sister Azula for blatant sequel bait. Then we FINALLY get a fight scene between Aang and Zuko 1 hour in the movie! These two are supposed to be rivals and this is the only fight scene between them in the entire film! And then it gets randomly interrupted by more shots of the Fire Nation invading as well as a scene of Zhao telling Iroh he’s planning to kill the moon spirit(WHICH WE ALREADY ESTABLISHED). When we get back to Aang he’s...doing a Tom and Jerry routine with Zuko...just...why!? Why would you write this into the script? Could no one see how AWFUL this looked on set!?
Eventually Zuko ends this and begins a fight with Aang. It’s actually pretty decent but it’s too late to give a crap. Cut to Katara, Sokka and Yue looking for Aang. Katara sees lights in a window and somehow comes to the conclusion Aang is in there. We go back to the fight scene. It ends with Katara freezing Zuko in ice which by the way is the only USEFUL thing she does in the ENTIRE film. Aang tells Katara he knows how to defeat the fire nation with the captain obvious info the Dragon provided. Before leaving Aang lets Zuko breath warning him to hide til the battle is over and telling him “We could be friends you know”....why did you put that line there? Putting it here instead of at the Blue Spirit stuff feels so out of place and random
Cut to Zhao and Iroh walking through the city and Zhao notes the waterbenders are getting stronger. He then pulls out his scroll..okay this is the 4th scene establishing what the scroll is!! Is this information necessary to repeat!? We get a brief shot of some Fire Nation troops getting scared by Appa...well that was pointless…. Team Avatar notices Zhao and Iroh and take interest in them(Despite the fact they are doing nothing to stand out) and Aang tells Sokka, Yue and Katara to follow them while he fights in the battle.
Then we get Zhao and Iroh in the spring and Zhao puts the Moon Spirit in its fish form in a bag(BTW the movie hasn’t bothered establishing the moon and ocean spirits took on Fish forms until this point unlike the show). He waxes philosophical for a bit wondering why the spirits would take on vulnerable forms. Iroh says it’s to teach us humility. I don’t see WHY it teaches us humility but whatever.
Katara Sokka and Yue show up and ask what’s going on. WHAT DO YOU THINK? Iroh tries to tell Zhao not to mess with the spirits or else it will throw the world out of balance. Zhao simply says the fire nation is too powerful to be afraid of child superstition and that now they are the gods and stabs the fish. Okay for starters. Iroh, Katara, Sokka you guys are RIGHT THERE!! DO SOMETHING!!! And second “We are now the gods” Why did they feel the need to throw that kind of motivation in there? In the show Zhao just wanted to depower the element that the Fire Nation was most weak to. Plain and simple.
Princess Yue falls ill and the moon turns red. And iroh...conjures fire out of nothing...even though the film established that Firebenders need fire to bend. This probably would be a big deal except the show already had firebenders conjure their own fire so it’s just stupid! Also why didn’t you do this earlier!? And Iroh doesn’t actually hurt anybody when he does this. He just scares Zhao and his men off! Unlike in the show where Iroh actually DID beat up Zhao’s soliders! So what was the point of that!?
Then we see random shots of people fighting. And because everyone is either wearing Dark blue or black I can’t tell who’s who. Did the Firebenders gain an advantage when the waterbenders lost their powers? I certainly can’t tell. We also see Aang looking around with...mild disinterest...um..DO SOMETHING!?
Cut to Iroh and the others and Iroh realizes Yue could sacrifice herself to save the spirit because she has some of the spirits life in her. Yue realizes he’s right but Sokka begs her not to. Yue says she has to and says THIS infamous line “it’s time we show the fire nation that we believe in our belief as much as they believe in theirs”...someone was PAID to write this line.After some more allegedly heartbreaking dialogue Yue goes into the pool and sacrifices herself. Is this movie expecting us to give a crap? We barely know Yue! We had less than 30 minutes to get attached to her and only had one character scene with her. In the show she was written to die as well but we had time to get to know her before dying.
Also this whole scene has no consequences for the fire nation. Because the scene of the ocean spirit merging with Aang to wreck the fire nation fleet never happens! So there’s no consequence to this entire scene. Meaning aside from Yue’s death because of the way the scene is adapted it’s entirely pointless.
Cut to Zhao on a bridge and Zuko appears. Zhao expresses surprise he’s alive and the two each take a stance. This entire scene is played up as a resolution to their ongoing rivalry except Zuko and Zhao have only interacted ONCE in the entire film. Compare that to the show where they butted heads over capturing Aang frequently. And before we can get a cool fight scene out of it Iroh shows up and tells Zuko to back off because….it said so in the script? Zhao tires to firebend but Iroh blocks it. He then tells Zhao his biggest mistake was standing alone….was that supposed to mean something? Was that the fulfillment of some narrative theme? Because I don't’ see it. Then some random waterbenders show up and drown Zhao. If that sounds like it came out of nowhere it does. It’s so out of nowhere it makes me wonder if originally they planned for the ocean spirit to kill Zhao but when the budget didn’t allow for it they went with this.
By the way this scene is even more insulting when you compare what happened in the show which was one of the best character moments in the whole series. In the show Zuko and Zhao DID throw down and you could feel the tension and hate in the scene where they fought. It got interrupted by the ocean spirit grabbing Zhao. And even after EVERYTHING Zhao did to him Zuko still tried to save him begging Zhao to take his hand. It showed that Zuko did have compassion for others inside him. But Zhao refused. He would rather DIE than be saved by Zuko. It was one of the most powerful moments in the show and movie does away with it. Zuko doesn’t even TALK during the movie scene FUCK THIS MOVIE.
Then we cut to Aang using waterbending to take down some soldiers. He gets up to the wall and has more Airbender flashbacks. Okay so the movie up until this point has been saying Aang has been having trouble with waterbending because he hasn’t been dealing with his painful emotions of the genocide of the Air Nomads. And he just...magically comes to terms with it. We don’t see him break down, we don’t see him get angry he just...comes to terms with it with no struggle even though the movie implied he would...excuse me…(Walks off. “AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!!!!!!!!” Walks back). Aang..somehow comes to terms with his emotions and summons a giant wall of water because they couldn’t afford Koifishzilla for this movie. This scares the fire nation to retreat...for some reason(Who cares the movie’s almost over…)
Once the fire nation troops are gone Aang comes down to the wall and everyone including the left over fire nation troops bow to him. Katara asks Aang to be their Avatar and Aang bows back showing he’s fully accepted his role as the Avatar….and it’s ruined because Aang looks like he’s about to burst into tears….I guess Noah Ringer realized how bad this movie was….
We cut to our Final scene with Ozai FINALLY bringing up Sozin’s comet and how they will use its power to create their own fire and you guessed it. Take over the world(Of course). And he assigns his daughter Azula to track down Aang, Zuko and Iroh. Azula agrees...and she looks like she’s about to burst out laughing. And then FINALLY the movie ENDS….PHEW….
Wow that was long...but the review isn’t over yet folks. Here are some topics I want to discuss in more detail that I couldn’t for the sake of the pacing of the plot summary.
Racebending.
Even before the movie was out there was a bit of controversy. If you’ve seen the show you should know that the cultures of the four nations are based off real life cultures. The Air Nomads are Tibetan, The Water Tribe is Inuit, The Earth Kingdom is China and the Fire Nation is Japan. So naturally a lot of people were pissed when there were white actors casted in the main roles.
Now to be fair nothing about Aang in the show screamed “Tibet” aside from his robes and his status as a monk.
No the racebending was more directed at Katara and Sokka. Who like the rest of the water tribe were based on Inuits but in the film were played by the caucasian Nicola Peltz and Jackson Rathbone respectively. Reportedly the casting wasn’t entirely the film crews choice. Nicola only got the role because her producer father “requested” she join the cast as Katara. Which meant they had to cast a white guy to play Sokka. But here’s the weird thing. In the movie all the Southern Water tribe extras are inuit. Which makes Sokka and Katara look like they don’t belong to their own tribe. What am I’m saying is if you’re gonna cast white actors as Eskimos you could at least be consistent!
Adding on Dev Patel’s casting as Zuko set the precedent for the Fire Nation being portrayed as Indian in the film. Which probably wouldn’t have been a big deal...except the evil fire nation are all dark skin and the good guys are white...oops.
M Night has stated he had planned to fix the Racebending complaints by casting an Asian actress as Toph for the sequel. Whether he would have followed through or not we may never really now.
Characters
One of the things Avatar the Last Airbender is known for is it’s amazing characters. So naturally it just stings all the more when the characters SUCK in this film.
Noah Ringer as Aang is what really hurts a lot of this film. He’s the main focus but it’s clear Noah just doesn’t have the acting skills to back it up. Every single time he talks he sounds so...detached and disinterested like he’s reading off a cue card. Normally that would be fine for other characters BUT IT’S NOT AANG. Aang is supposed to be an eternally optimistic bag of fun who knows when to get serious and can kick some ass but in the movie he’s just so...sad. And don’t get me wrong Aang has moments where he’s sad and dour in the cartoon but Noah Ringer portrays Aang like this THROUGH THE WHOLE FILM. That’s not what Aang’s like!
Nicola Peltz’s Katara is almost universally considered to be the worst adapted from cartoon to film and I have to agree on that. Unlike Noah who at least shows off different emotions from time to time Nicola has the same expression throughout most of the movie. Katara doesn’t sound like that! In almost all her scenes especially towards the end she looks like she’s about to cry any moment and all of her important character building scenes are either given to Aang or skipped over entirely and she never gets a moment to throw down.
Jackson Rathbone at least looks like Sokka but he doesn’t act like Sokka. Sokka is supposed to be a funny comic relief guy who has intelligence underneath the goofy exterior. Jackson is constantly frowning throughout the whole film like he’s Anakin in the prequels. Reportedly most of Jacksons’ scenes that showed off his his humor side were cut from the film but from the few glimpses of the classic Sokka we know and love in the film, I’m not convinced he would have been good in the role
Dev Patel is a good actor but he’s not Zuko. Zuko in the first season is a firestorm waiting to happen with humanity underneath. But Dev’s performance doesn’t really capture that. Aside from that scene where he’s dining with Zhao we don’t really see him get intense and angry just depressed. And as I pointed out earlier the filmmakers didn’t even bother to make him look like Zuko in the cartoon. I mean yes he has the scar but it’s so barely visible it’s insulting. At least Dev is trying from what I can tell but he just isn’t given the right material to work with.
In terms of the other minor characters well Iroh and Yue are probably the closest to their cartoon versions. Pakku is really different from his cartoon version lacking that versions arc of being sexist and learning to get over it but that’s justifiable given you don’t have time to work in an arc like that in the film.
But the villains are the worst. Asaif Maimbe is a TERRIBLE Zhao. For one big reason HE’S NOT INTIMIDATING. Zhao wasn’t the most interesting villain in the cartoon but at least he had moments where he was a real threat. The way Asaif delivers his lines is so casual it’s almost funny. I’ve already gone into the problems with Cliff Curtis as the firelord so I won’t go over it here. And from the brief glimpses we got of Azula from this film I don’t think she would have been much better.
And that’s another major issue. For the villains of the movie nothing is really done to make the fire nation imposing or a major threat. Throughout the whole movie they’re nothing but incompetent and the cinematography and music doesn’t show them being a major threat. Of course there’s another big reason the fire nation just isn’t threatening which leads nicely into…
Bending
The bending in this movie sucks. I already went over it partially in the plot summary but it’s such a huge issue I thought I’d dig deeper.
One of the big reasons people were looking forward to this film was seeing bending on the big screen and they couldn’t even get THAT right. The bending of this film is awful. In the show every movement matched up with how an element moves and each element had its own unique and diverse style that matched up that element perfectly. None of this is in the film. Everyone just waves their arms around like they are dancing until the element launches. The movements have nothing to do with what the element does. Shyamalan.said it’s because he saw bending as working like pumping up an air cannon and then launching. The dance movements build up the energy and then you release. Which is just stupid! It’s just a lazy excuse to not bother with the choreography. And if that’s the idea nothing is done to convey it in the film!
But of course the most talked about issue with bending is this. In the movie firebenders need existing fire to bend whereas in the show they could create their own fire. The reasoning behind this change was to make things more evenly matched. Except the fact the fire nation has an unfair advantage is the whole point! They’re the bad guys who are winning the war! And of course the change when you actually put thought into it makes Firebenders weaker. Because as much as we like to use fire as an element in fantasy works if you wanna get technical it’s not, it’s a chemical reaction. Fire only occurs naturally through extreme circumstances and it can easily be taken away. Put out the fire and firebenders are powerless. And what puts out fire?...oh yeah...EARTH AIR AND WATER.(But of course they never do this in the film.)
Horrible Direction
There’s a lot of evidence to suggest that Shyamalan isn’t 100% responsible for how this mess of a film turned out. Apparently he did want to make an accurate adaptation but then the studio got involved and messed up things including rewriting his script. That being said I’m still listing him as one of the problems because he’s still the director. He has to share the blame. And to put it simply M Night as a horrible choice for director in the first place.
His best films have always been dramas. Sixth Sense is about the supernatural but it’s also about a man helping a boy deal with his problem, Unbreakable is a superhero film but it’s about the drama of becoming one. None of his resume screams action film director. The closest besides this to an action film he’s directed is After Earth but that was made after this and was a whole other mess.
Shyamalan’s lack of experience directing action really shows in the film. I’ve already gone into how badly the action scenes were shot and how little of them they are in the film. I’m not sure how much of the writing is his fault and how much is the studio’s but I guess we’ll never know for sure.
Final thoughts
You know...I’ve accepted at this point that nothing is ever gonna replace the original Avatar the Last Airbender. It was an amalgamation of all the right things at all the right time. It was childish but it didn’t talk down to them and wasn’t afraid to tackle mature topics. It was silly but it was serious. It was timeless. Everything was so perfectly put together. It’s lightning that will never strike again.
The Last Airbender by contrast feels like a cruel joke. An unintentional parody of the original series.The writing sucks, every piece of dialogue is either exposition, forced, rushed or narrated, the editing feels both slow and rushed at the same time, the cinematography is bland and for a movie that’s supposed to be an adaptation of a cartoon it feels bland and dull.
As you can imagine plans had been in place for a sequel but the cold reception combined with a mediocre box office killed any chance of it. The film also picked up 5 Razzie awards, Worst Picture of the year, Worst Director, Worst Screenplay, Worst misuse of 3D and Worst Supporting Actor for Jackson Rathbone. All of them were WELL deserved in this reviewer's honest opinion.
But in a strange way...I’m actually kinda glad I finally watched it. It was horrible to be sure but it was very fun ripping it apart. It’s just the perfect film you love to hate.
As some of you probably know Avatar the last airbender is being given another shot at live action this time as a Netflix TV series. I had high hopes for it at first...but after it was announced that the original creators were leaving production I can’t help but have a bad feeling in my gut...
Still. No matter what happens we’ll always have the cartoon. And nothing's ever gonna destroy it’s legacy.
Thanks for joining me on this review. See ya guys next time.
Comments
Post a Comment